I know that this is kind of weird and
out of the blue, but I was organizing my email when something happened. Maybe
it’s because I’m so used to focusing on something else, I find it amusing to
think that every time I check my email, your reply has always been there
staring at me when I do work and other stuff online. I starred your mail, and
it’s sitting right there amongst other work related emails, which means this
has been going on for seven whole years and I never really bothered about that
until today. It’s not that I haven’t read it, I definitely read it back in
2018, but I guess I have a lot of free time and I wanted to further amuse
myself and reread what you wrote to me back then about our breakup. And oh boy,
I wasn’t ready for the fact that you didn’t justify the paragraphs. That, and
you were using double dashes to make em dashes. I actually chuckled from that,
thinking of the fact that to me you were the perfect writer. And despite that,
I still think you are. When you read this later (through the process I can only
describe as somehow), for some reason in my imagination, you were
there judging me based on the errors you can find, and somehow that didn’t
offend me. Because again, you are the A.S., and I think that
amuses me somehow, it killed me.
Don’t
worry, this is not an ex who wants you back. This isn’t gonna be another one of
those, “hey I fucked up, I miss us” kind of thing—this is
just someone who is reflecting on what happened back then, and to tell you how
much I disagreed with your reply.
I
was never your trophy. And you knew that. You knew about a lot of things, but
you lied to me in that letter. You sugarcoat things a lot for a younger me to
digest. It’s either that, or if that fact is entirely untrue, then perhaps the
you from back then didn’t understand it aswell. Which is fair, we were both
young, dumb and inexperienced in life, and I’m guessing we will probably
approach things the same way today; for I believe it takes a lifetime to ever
figure out that there ain’t no lifetime that’s ever figured out. In all
honesty, I am sending this to you for one reason only; all my previous attempts
were regrets, now that I remembered that I tried. I remember that time when I
worked at a food stall of some sorts, and I texted you a long essay or
something, and it ended up with us arguing again. That was around five or six
years ago. I don’t remember trying again after that other than the time when
we just broke up, but I do remember the last time to be
hostile and filled with disrespect, from my part. It has been years, and I’m a
different man, so I am sending you this as a proper apology.
You
wrote in that letter about how you were trying to fix something broken. Well, I
was too—it was mutual. I also told you back then that I had trouble sleeping;
these days I sleep like a tardigrade, perhaps too much, almost all the time.
You told me that I was the “best kind of pain” and I bet you regretted
ever thinking that, considering the fact that as who you are today, you must’ve
had newer, better kinds of pain to put on your pedestal. We’re proper adults
now, and if you don’t think of me as something of a puppy love of some sort
compared to what you had since then, you would’ve been joking to me. You told
me that there wasn’t a single fiber of you that is not filled with “exuberance”
at the mere thought of me; and I think that is a definite lie—at the very
least, some parts of you hated me—and if you did, perhaps you
should do so a lot more than you ever did. I remember disagreeing when you
wrote that our love is short lived and tragic but still had some worthiness for
it to be celebrated, but today, I read that again and in a way, I was thankful
too. I do not deserve to be the reason behind the existence of your first poem,
or the fact that you started writing; it was in your blood all along. If I was
the reason, then how come you write much better than I do? Because if that is
the case—and I know it isn’t—you will write things in simpler
words, not in your A-esque style. I am not going to bullshit you,
I can tell if it’s a sentence made by you at a glance; and I’ve read a lot of
books from famous authors, and none—I repeat, none—write as beautifully as you.
In a way, it’s a shame, really. Because I can never read your writings ever
again, but it also meant you’re happier; you and me, we don’t write anymore
when we stopped being such sad fucks, I assume.
It
irked me so much when you wrote that perhaps, someday, I get to meet someone
who understands that my no’s meant yes. Because my god, that was so fucking
cringe, I hated myself for remembering that. You told me I loved you immensely
and that I did; but it was unhealthy because I wasn’t in love—I was obsessed—and
you did the things you did to me as a reaction to that unhealthy, toxic
behaviour, and I am sorry that you were the victim. I’m sorry for not being
enough (despite the fact that you wrote that I am) and for wasting
your time with me. But in a way, maybe that has to happen. You fell out of love
for me; and if you didn’t, I would’ve never been the man I am today, the same
way you won’t be who you are as well in the present time. Although, I can’t say
for sure if you are happy, but knowing how persistent you are with
some things, I’d like to think that you are happy.
It
wasn’t a shame at all, falling for you all those years ago. You weren’t all trouble.
Sure, you’re a pain in the ass, but you were my pain in the
ass, and I was not man enough to handle you. Of course you can be a headache to
me (like come on, what were you thinking asking for a diamond ring, I was a
goddamn middle-class university student for fuck’s sake), but again, you were
like that because I wasn’t good enough for you. If it weren’t for you, I
would’ve never thought about how important love languages are; you and me were
never meant to be—or last—to begin with, considering you always had
an appetite for gifts and I was never into that because I grew up never wanting
expensive toys, only people who genuinely made me feel loved—to which I have
accepted to be very much impossible due to myself being born
as a man. I admit, for a long time I thought of you as a subject of resentment,
frustration and nothing but a past reminder of a pain to avoid; but now that I
am older I have a clearer view of things, and you are—hopefully as I am to
you—a lesson; on who to choose and what to never become.
When
we broke up, I remember you wrote something around the themes of ascencion;
you described it as me trying to clip your wings and halt your growth, or
something akin to it. I was so furious when I read that, and I was so upset
because to me you never understood my pain as the one who was abandoned. And to
that, you told me it hurt for you, too; but all I can think of is how unfair it
is, how much I was suffering at that moment because you left me.
Thank
you, for doing that. For being courageous enough to do it for us. It took me a
while to understand that a breakup never needed mutual consent, it isn’t like
sex. You had to be selfish, because it was the most selfless thing to do—for my
sake as well.
Thank
you for abandoning me. Thank you for doing what was needed to be done. And
again, thank you for loving me back then, in your own A kind of way. I wish we
did better, but we had to be bad to be better for whoever it is who ends up
with us later. It’s regrettable to think of each other as a learning tool, but
that exactly what it was—it was practice. Maybe, just maybe, there
is a version of us out there in “althernate” (I’m making fun of your typo,
haha) universe who ends up happy together, but as you not-so-famously wrote to
me as well, “we are in the exact places that we should be” —and
I too, dare not change that.
Like
I said before, this isn’t a letter expressing anything about wanting you back.
I just wrote this impulsively, all because I’m amused at the reply you sent me
all those years ago. When I read it again, I can’t help but smile when I
recount on how immature we both are. I know for a fact that I don’t love you
because I don’t remember how your voice sounded like anymore. I don’t know what
happened to you ever since I accidentally saw your image in your sister's
Instagram story, and it has been ages since I used that platform (or any other
social medias of any kind). I have enjoyed being a hermit a bit too much and I
care about much less things these days, I even got sort of fat and got
endlessly joked on for looking like Shin Chan whenever I wear
bright red. Perhaps you’re with someone now, or better, married
(congratulations if that were the case!) but whatever circumstances you’re in,
I hope you know that I genuinely wish you well. My heart has softened, a lot. I
myself, has gone softer; and I’m happy with mundane everyday things as if I’m
looking forward to it each day. I find it funny you used a Crisis on
Earth-X quote, I just finished watching that earlier this year and the
time gap between you and me watching that somehow bothered me, somehow. You
told me to forgive you, but perhaps, I needed to ask for your forgiveness as
well.
I
have so many things to apologize to you about. I’m sorry for writing things
publicly to smear your name to our mutual friends. It was a childish, pathetic
and sad attempt to tell the world how wronged I was. To make people believe
that you were the villain, to make things so hard for you. I
still believe there are things you did—both behind and to my face—that are
definitely bad things, but maybe I was wrong and that they never happened in
the first place. Besides, I was a jerk to you as a boyfriend, and I hurt you a
lot so even if you did those things perhaps I deserved it as well; but I
don’t—emphasis on don’t—feel that way anymore. I’m sorry for
turning your sister away from you for a time, I was too distraught to care
about what your family meant to you, and to try and break a family that is
already broken is very irresponsible of me. In all honesty I regret not
understanding that I was being manipulative; I swear I do not know what’s right
or wrong because I wasn’t a man; I was a kid who thought he understood the
world. I was never a good listener, and my girl is the one thing I never cared
to listen to. I’m sorry for hurting you. There is no more bitterness residing
in my heart whenever I think of you, and there are only good things I will ever
wish for whenever that rarely happens.
In
that letter, you promised something to me. You promised that you’ll always love
me, as the person I am. You also promised that that won’t ever change. But I
have a request for you—and my request is for you to break this promise. Because
the person you loved back then is no more but an echo that will never be heard
ever again. And in truth, both you and I know that I don’t have to make that
request, because it is not far-fetched for both of us to have met a much better
love than we had back when we were together. I hope you get to properly love
everyone who came after me. And by that, I meant loving them without hurting them.
To yearn for happiness without ever making anyone’s heart to be something of a
collateral damage of sorts. To properly love yourself as well, and to put down
your crown—the one made of thorns—and never wear it back. I hope you never
write again, because to do so would mean you’re unhappy again. To stop being
the antithesis of happiness.
I
hope your sister is doing well. She used to text me a lot, saying that I am
cooler than Mike Tyson for some reason; but Tyson’s a sellout after that fight
with Jake Paul. I’m doing fine—if you were actually wondering. I like not
having the spotlight on me as I do all the things I wanted to do, and I have
all the time in the world to do whatever I liked; although I’m starting to not
enjoy doing the things I used to dream of back when I was a kid. I partially
wrote this in hopes that you would let me know of ways to not just apologize
but to also make it up to you, but knowing how kind you are in your heart you
will never make that request to me. I hope that you are now happy with someone
who perfectly matches you in all aspects—perhaps a pretty boy because you
always loved pretty boys. If you haven’t, don’t worry. There’s somebody out
there who’s looking for you, and someday he’ll find you too. And of course above
all, I hope you get what you wanted; the simple thing we all want for
ourselves—happiness.
You'd be happy to know, uttering your name
after all these years; it no longer left a bitter taste.
Godspeed, A. For everything in your
life.
(Oh, and you don’t have
to replace my hoodies, I don’t even wear hoodies anymore these days. You can
use them for cleaning tables or something, I actually will not mind that at
all.)
Extra context: I wrote
this as a reply to A one random night while organizing emails after 7 years; it
never went through because her email is full (lol!) so I figured I'll just
change some of the content to hide some names, admit some wrongs and write
something real.
I wish you'd be properly happy, everything here comes straight from my heart.